Ice Cream Shop

While our premium homemade ice creams have some unusual sounding names (Ditch Tea Delight anyone?), their descriptions may be just enough to get you down to our Ice Cream Shoppe for a visit!

While you're here you can enjoy a tasty bite to eat with a cold glass of milk or other refreshment, browse our book offerings, and stock up on some Hartzler milk and butter. We also carry a select assortment of Amish cheeses and other small novelties.

Hours
Monday - Saturday: 10 AM - 7 PM
 

 

Our Menu


Ice Cream Flavors

Click here to view our ice cream flavors!

Ice Cream Specialties

Banana Split
Three mounds of our homemade creamy vanilla custard smothered with strawberry, chocolate, and pineapple toppings, a banana split on the sides, and topped with real whipped cream, a cherry, and chopped nuts.

Turtle Sundae
A tasty serving of our homemade vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, pecans, whipped cream & a cherry.

Cow Pie Sundae
Our own freshly baked “cow pie” brownie topped with our homemade vanilla custard, hot fudge, real whipped cream and a cherry.

Barn Buster Parfait
A parfait layered with our homemade vanilla custard, hot fudge, Spanish peanuts and topped with real whipped cream and a cherry.

Old Fashioned Sundaes
Choose from the following toppings: Chocolate, Strawberry, Hot Fudge, Pineapple, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Caramel, or Cherry

Flurries
Choose from the following: Oreos, Snickers, Reese’s Cups, Caramel & Pecans, M&Ms, Cookie dough.

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Made with our Creamy Soft Custard

Cow Chip Sandwich
Two large Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies filled with our Creamy Soft Custard and rolled in Mini Chocolate Chips

Ice Cream Cakes

Minty Ditch Tea
Hot Fudge and Crushed Oreo all between our Premium Vanilla Custard and Ditch Tea Ice Cream.

Heifer Trails
Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, and Reese’s Cups all between our Premium Vanilla Custard and Heifer Trails Ice Cream.

Turtle Pecan
Hot Fudge, Caramel, and Pecans all between two layers of our Premium Vanilla Custard and Butter Pecan.

Hot Mud
Hot Fudge and Crushed Ore all between our Premium Vanilla Custard and Hot Mud Ice Cream.

Strawberry
Strawberries and Vanilla Wafers all between our Premium Vanilla Custard and Strawberry Ice Cream.

Milk Shakes and Malts

  • Hot Fudge
  • Strawberry
  • Vanilla
  • Peanut Butter
  • Pineapple
  • Chocolate
  • Caramel
  • Marshmallow
  • Cherry

Root Beer Floats

Sandwiches

Angus Beef Burger
Delicious Angus Burger topped with your choice of Veggies

Grilled Chicken Pita
Warmed grilled chicken breast served on a warm pita bread & topped with your choice of Veggies

Turkey Bacon Club
Slices of all-natural turkey, bacon and Swiss cheese heated and served on toasted whole-grain hoagie & topped with your choice of Veggies

Fish Filet Sandwich
Fish served on a toasted bun, tartar sauce & topped with your choice of Veggies

Chicken Salad
Delicious chicken salad served on toasted homemade raisin bread & topped with your choice of Veggies

Veggie Pita
Lettuce, tomato, onion, swiss & American cheeses served on a pita with homemade cucumber sauce

Farmer’s Hoagie
Slices of turkey, ham, bacon, Swiss & American cheese served hot or cold on whole-grain hoagie & topped with your choice of Veggies

Crispy Chicken Bacon Wrap
Our crispy chicken strips and bacon rolled into a wrap and topped with your choice of veggies

Fresh Spring Salads

  • Grilled Chicken Salad
  • Side Salad
  • Garden Salad
  • Club Salad
  • Chicken Strip Salad
  • Chef’s Salad

Sides

  • Waffle Fries
  • Soup - Seasonal Item
  • Onion Rings

Beverages

  • Hartzler’s Own Milk - Whole, 2%, Skim or Chocolate
  • Hot Chocolate
  • Brewed Iced Tea
  • Coffee
  • Gourmet Latte - Mocha Moo, Royal Vanilla, or Caramel Cream

Frozen Cow Latte

*Summer Specialty Item

  • Mocha Moo
  • Royal Vanilla
  • Caramel Cream