Ice Cream Flavors

Banana Pudding
We use Real Ripe Bananas, mix them into our OH-SO Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream and sprinkle in some Crushed Vanilla Wafers -- and Voila! Banana Pudding!
 

Black Cherry
Love Black Cherry? This one is loaded -- Black Cherry Ice Cream with Black Cherry Chunks
 

Black Raspberry Cream
sMOOth and Creamy -- Black Raspberry Ice Cream
 

Blushing Bessie
Wild Cherry Ice Cream with Black Cherry Chunks, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips, and Vanilla Wafers
 

Butter Pecan
Obviously a very popular flavor... Butter Pecan loaded with Roasted, Salted Pecans
 

Cherry Cheese Cake
Cherry Swirl & Crushed Graham Crackers in our delightful Cheesecake Ice Cream. This flavor is part of the Harvey's Orchard Summer Flavors
 

Chicken Feed
This is actually a spin-off of Cow Pies & Cream. We pile in lots of Almonds, Butterscotch Swirl and chunks of Grandma's Homemade Brownies (literally) into batches of our Vanilla Ice Cream. The result? Although we have never done it, we think this is what it would look like if you threw chicken feed into vanilla ice cream.
 

Chocolate
The sMOOthest, Creamiest Chocolate you'll ever need!
 

Chocolate Royale
Love Raspberries and Chocolate? We do too!! Raspberry Puree, Cashews Pieces and Chocolate Chunks in our sMOOth Chocolate Ice Cream
 

Coconut Almond Fudge
Think Almond Joy® candy bars! Fudge & Almonds in Coconut Ice Cream
 

Cookies & Cream
Crushed Oreo's in our Premium Vanilla Ice Cream
 

Cookie Dough
Creamy Vanilla with bits of Cookie Dough
 

Cowboy Crunch
Creamy Butter Pecan Ice Cream loaded with Toffee Chunks and Chocolate Swirl
 

Cow Pies and Cream
If you have ever lived on a farm and worked around cows, you will understand how this ice cream got its name ('nuff said). We use Grandma Hartzler's Chunks of Chewy Brownies (literally), Salted Pecans and Chocolate Swirl in our Creamiest of Vanilla Ice Cream. It's like a brownie sundae in every bite!
 

Ditch Tea Delight
A lot of folks are curious about the origins of the name for this Mint Ice Cream with Oreos®. Our family used to enjoy a delicious fresh mint tea in the summers. The only catch... we kids had to pick those fuzzy mint leaves ourselves out of a large ditch on the farm before Mom could make it. We called this "Ditch" Tea.
 

Farm House
Just Plain Maraschino Cherry Chunks in Our Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream
 

Heifer Trails
Hartzler's Signature Flavor!! Besides Vanilla, this is our best seller... A Smooth Peanut Butter Ice Cream with Reese's Peanut Butter Cup®, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunks, and Peanut Butter Swirl
 

Hot Fudge Brownie
Chewy Chunks of Grandma Hartzler's Homemade Brownies (literally!) and Fudge Swirl in our Heavenly Chocolate Ice Cream
 

Hot Mud
Zack, Gene Hartzler's son, named this one. You'll have to ask him for more details. Oreo® Cookies, Marshmallows and Chocolate Ice Cream come together for a fine, rich treat.
 

Maple Nut
Premium Maple Nut Ice Cream with large Walnut Chunks
 

Marshland
A WHOPPER of an Ice Cream! Our creamy Chocolate Ice Cream with a mix of soft Marshmallow Swirl and Whopper® Candies
 

Mocha Carmel Chip
If you love coffee like we do, you'll love our Mocha Ice Cream with Caramel Swirl and Chocolate Chips
 

Mocha Mud
Mocha Ice Cream with crushed Chocolate Cookies and Fudge Swirl
 

Monkey Business
Fresh Ripe Banana's are mixed into our Vanilla Ice Cream, swirled with Peanut Butter and crushed Chocolate Cookies
 

Moonure
A great name for a fabulous Ice Cream!! What's not to like about our sMOOth Chocolate Ice Cream loaded with Caramel Swirl, Cheesecake Chunks, Salted Pecans, and Dark Chocolate Chips
 

Raspberry Royal
Rich Vanilla Ice Cream with Swirls of Raspberries, Chunks of Semi-Sweet Chocolate and Salted Cashews
 

Orange Dreamsicle
Do you have delightful memories of eating Orange Creamsicles in the heat of the summer? Then you'll love this Light & Creamy Orange Ice Cream
 

Road Hog
This is what impatient drivers have often called farmers operating large, slow-moving vehicles on country roads. It's what we call an old favorite that should probably be eaten slowly. It begins with a Butter Pecan Ice Cream and then is wonderfully transformed through the addition of generous amounts of chopped Snickers® and Fudge
 

Strawberry Cream
sMOOth and Creamy Strawberry
 

Trip to the Dentist
We like to say "It's the best trip to the dentist you'll ever have!" Chocolate Ice Cream with Reese's Peanut Butter Cup® Candy
 

Vanilla
Our #1 seller. Rich and Creamy made with Pure Vanilla Extract